Wednesday, October 7, 2026
On Being A Real American and a Real Christian
Like, say, am I a real Virginian? Every once in a while, folks will make the claim that living inside Beltway doesn’t qualify a person as Virginian, that coming from the frenetically paced crucible of this region effectively de-Virginia-izes a soul. “Northern Virginia just isn’t Virginia,” some might say. “You’re not a real Virginian if you’re from Northern Virginia.”
I would argue to the contrary, and as evidence could present my having lived within the boundaries of the great state of Virginia for the vast supermajority of my life. I attended elementary, middle, and high school in Virginia. I am a graduate of the University of Virginia. I’ve been a Virginia taxpayer since I was 16 and working at a movie theater, and have paid taxes to the state of Virginia from every paycheck I’ve ever received, Lord help me. Not enough? I share a birthday with General Robert E. Lee, who…as the commanding general of the Army of Northern Virginia…might look askance at anyone who suggested Northern Virginia wasn’t Virginia. Lee, of course, was so Virginian that he kinda sorta forgot to be American, so more pointedly, am I a real American?
I was born in this nation’s capital, a citizen by birth, the child of two citizens whose lineage goes back a nontrivial distance. On my father’s side, I go back to the tide of Welsh and Scots-Irish immigration in the late 19th and early 20th century. On my mother’s side, I can trace my blood lineage all the way back to a man named Richard Howland, who came over as a bondservant on the Mayflower.
But does that make me any more American than someone who…of their own volition and with intent…took the Oath of Allegiance yesterday?
I would, obviously, say no. There is no difference, other than the significantly higher effort the naturalized citizen put into the process. If America is not a land of ideals, then it is nothing.
As a Christian, the answer to that question is also pretty straightforward. We’re not Christian by blood or heritage, but by faith and a personal commitment to do what Jesus has asked of us.
The Apostle Paul reminds us of this, every time we read him.
In his letter to the church at Phillipi, the most influential early follower of Jesus, whose energy and dynamism were absolutely central to the spread of the faith...and he’s the dude who takes no salary as a point of pride. Oh sure, it’s fine for some, he says. If people really need it. But for me? I’m not going there.
And that’s in the face of a set of credentials that was as impressive as anything the early Christian movement could have expected.
The funny thing about Paul sharing this list of credentials with the folks at Philippi was that they kind of already knew him, and knew him well. It was a church that he himself had founded, likely in around the year 50 in the Common Era. The short letter he wrote to them reflected their relationship, and that relationship was a good one.
The letter reflects that. It’s an expression of the love he felt for the community there, particularly as they had supported him through times of challenge. This letter was written during one of Paul's many imprisonments, most likely written from jail in Rome in the early 60s.
Paul thanks them for both their material support during his incarceration, but also for their prayers and care. What makes this sweet little thank you note so interesting theologically is its focus on expressing the nature of Jesus of Nazareth, and particularly the humility and self-giving nature of Christ. That's the focus of the well known hymn to Christ in Philippians 2:5-11, in which Paul encourages his readers to empty themselves of themselves, and be humble even in the face of their newly found connection to God.
In Philippians 3, Paul offers up something similar, but with a more pointed focus. Paul knew his background and his heritage, and recounted it to the folks at Philippi as a way of reminding them what mattered. In every way, he had done what he needed to do to be an identitarian. He’d studied the Torah and the Prophets ferociously, training at the feet of Gamaliel, grandson of Hillel, and one of the most renowned rabbis of that era.
There was very little doubt of Paul’s skill, training, and blood heritage. He had prepared himself in every conceivable way for leading a Jewish community. That was not the life he ended up living. Having had a powerful and transforming experience of Christ, Paul found himself radically changing the arc of his life.
What mattered was the transformative relationship he had with that odd man from Nazareth. It’s the kind of relationship that knocks you to the ground and blinds you, that shatters everything you thought you knew about yourself, and every preconceived notion you have about who you are.
Paul’s faith in the justice, grace, mercy, and love of Christ was what defined his life, and what gave him value. It is that relationship that allowed Paul to endure, and to press on through the considerable trials and difficulties of his existence, certain that there was a purpose to his life.
The other stuff? It helped, without question. Paul’s deep cultural knowledge of the Hebrew bible did sort of come in handy later on. But for all of his training and all of his experience, Paul completely rejected the idea that those things had any value.
What mattered was that his life had been utterly upended by the shattering grace of Jesus. Did it matter who he was and what his lineage was? Did blood or soil mean anything to Paul at all? Nope.
Ethnonationalism, heritage, and lineage also meant exactly jack-squat to Jesus, and there is no honest and plain-text reading of the Gospels that would suggest otherwise.
Strange that some of us seem to have so much trouble grasping that.
Thursday, August 20, 2026
The Crumbs
Ants have a solid foothold on every continent but one, and that one is…kind of ironic, right?
Mostly, my encounters seem to be with the nearly ubiquitous Tetramorium Immigrans, the little black pavement ants that invariably find their way into mid-Atlantic homes when the weather gets warmer. They’ll come noodling into bathrooms, or booping across kitchen counters, and where one comes leaving a little pheromone trail, it means more will follow. “Dave, we’ve got ants again,” Rache will say, and I know it’ll be my sad duty to spray. Otherwise, I try not to kill them if I can avoid it, because they neither bite, sting, nor carry diseases.
So long as they stay in the yard, they’re welcome. There’s been a constant stream of Tetamorium Immigrans flowing across my carport this season, a relentless bustling rush of tiny chitinous bodies running right along the brick wall of the house, along a groove in the concrete, and then down and under the driveway. If it’s an average-sized nest, there are fifteen to thirty thousand of them down there, and so that flow doesn’t ever seem to stop, morning, noon and night, as relentless a bustle as any major human thoroughfare at the height of rush hour, with the only differences being 1) size and 2) the fact that the ants are actually moving.
Should I begrudge them this? I know, given the frequency with which I receive flyers from exterminators eager to kill every insect on my property, that there are some folks who struggle with the idea that there might be any unauthorized living creatures on their land. Kill the bugs! Sure, spray kills mosquitoes and ticks, but it also kills nearly every other insect. It kills the ants and spiders, kills the beetles and butterflies, kills all of them, all for our convenience. We human beings can be weirdly territorial that way, mindlessly guarding even the crumbs that fall on the periphery of our lives.
The Gospel of Matthew delves into that a little bit, in a strange passage about a foreign woman who just wouldn’t back down, a woman who was not just subordinate because she was a woman, but also because she was a Canaanite, a Syrophoenician, to be exact. She was as other as other could be, and was treated as such by both the disciples and by Jesus himself.
First, she is ignored, as she cries out in faith for the healing of her daughter. She’s not a Judean. But she won’t stop, and the disciples finally get so sick of her persistence that they ask Jesus to send her packing. As the woman comes and kneels at Christ’s side, Jesus drops a surprisingly cutting metaphor. “It is not fair to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.” He’s the food, the children are Israel, and the dogs...well...she and her daughter are the subhuman creatures.
But her faith and her wit drives her to come back with an even better line, and Jesus...impressed by both her faith and her relentlessness...very publicly backs down. She is given what she has so persistently sought. Her daughter is healed.
It’s worth noting which Gospels have this story, and which Gospels do not. Mark has it, Mark, the earliest of the Gospels, Mark, clearly written for a community of Jewish Christians before everything in Judah fell apart. Matthew has it too, Matthew, whose primary goal is to show how Jesus meets and exceeds the demands of Torah and the Prophets, again for a primarily Jewish audience. Luke and John, which were written for Gentiles, all of whom were outside that first fold of Galileans and Judeans? They don’t have this story.
The difference seems obvious. There were ethnically insular Christian communities at the dawn of the church, who assumed that the Gospel belonged only to their particular race, nation, or ethnic group. The communities that first received Mark and Matthew tended that way. So Mark and Matthew made sure to remember to them that one time when Jesus allowed himself to be seen publicly changing his mind. Jesus himself, yielding to the insistence of a foreign woman who just wanted to experience God’s healing and grace, allowing his hardness to fall away.
We know, we do, that this selfishness of soul still lives in the heart of humankind, and that we are prone to treating certain others as if they are not human, as if their hopes and their sorrows aren’t as known to God as our own. It seems just part of our lingering soul-blindness, that inability to offer the grace we mistakenly assume is ours and ours alone.
But I do wonder, at times, if the measure of the grace we will receive might rest in our willingness to show compassion not just to our human neighbors, but also to those creatures that really and truly aren’t us, and that we consider less than us.
Just to be clear, I’m not considering converting to Jainism. Nor will I…and my wife will be relieved to hear this…be scattering crumbs for the ants in our kitchen. If there were some way to come to an agreement with ants, in which they’d only come into the kitchen to clean up debris between the hours of one and four am, we’d be good. But I don’t speak any of the many varieties of ant-language, as the pheromones I produce aren’t of much help.
That said, I’m aware, as I watch the ant highway to my compost bin, that they’re God’s creatures too, and I watch where I step. I’m aware, as I tend to my garden, that the dozens of species of native bees and little wasps and tiny shining flies that bustle from my flowering mint to my bolting basil to those great gorgeous okra blossoms are the very farthest things from pests.
Sure, they’re small and their lives are fleeting. But so are we, and so are ours.
Monday, May 4, 2026
The Deathbed Confession
It is, in that, a declaration intended to be both unifying and integrative.
Like the Barmen Declaration, which challenged the usurpation of the church by the Nazi regime, or the Belhar Confession, which renounces the spiritual blight of racist segregationism from the depths of South African apartheid, most confessions rise from a condition of conflict, and give the faithful a clear vision of where the Beloved Community must stand.
They are a fierce call to integrity in life together. It's why Presbyterians remember confessions, and why the Book of Confessions is part of the Presbyterian Church (USA)'s Constitution.
Our era poses plenty of challenges for the church, and so...Presbyterians being who we are...we've convened a committee to come up with a statement that speaks powerfully to where God is calling us right now. They've done the work, and now we've been asked, by that committee, to give that confession a read.
Then, we have been asked to sit with it a while. Where it troubles us, reflect meaningfully on why, and then consider it some more. When we've done that, respond.
The confession they've drafted for our consideration does not yet have a name, other than "Proposed New Confession." This doesn't quite have the ring of "Second Helvetic" or "Westminster," although it's probably already catchier than "Brief Statement." Were I a marketer, I'd really want us to have a stronger brand identity at launch.
So how does it read? What does it say? What are we called to affirm, and what crisis calls us to a moment of choosing and shared witness?
The language is reflective of the academic-progressive character of the PC(USA), and marks our denomination's continued emphasis on inclusion and welcome. It has four sections. The first, entitled Image of the Triune God, lays out our understanding of the nature of...surprise surprise...the Triune God. It does so in language that moves even further down the inclusive language path than the Brief Statement of Faith. In tone and semiotic choices, it's fuzzier and more prone to poesy than other confessions, but nonetheless retains a vital and necessary core witness to the nature of our Creator.
I particularly appreciated its Augustinian expression of the Trinity as Love, which shows some solid theological chops cast with concision and poetry. It's in essence the same understanding of an interrelationship of love that C.S. Lewis expresses in Mere Christianity, even if it's wearing some soft flannel pajamas.
One could quibble, I suppose, with some of the language. Like, say, the use of the word "affection" as a wiffle-ball euphemism for "sexual orientation." Them's ain't the same things, y'all, not by a long shot. στοργή is not Ἔρως is not ἀγάπη, right?
Generally speaking, it's perfectly fine.
The second section, Turning Away From God's Image, establishes the nature of the crisis.
In four powerful paragraphs, it lays the essence of the challenge of our age. The first three name that challenge: that humankind has once again lost itself in the thrall of wealth and power. This love of Mammon and the sword has corrupted the witness of faith, and as a prophetic critique, it's dead on. It stings like Amos and Micah, and delivers the sort of uppercut to heresy that would do Saint Nicolas proud.
In the final paragraphs, there's a clear naming of our deepest moral and spiritual challenge: the mutual careening towards the sabotage of our entire ecosystem. Taken together, those paragraphs are succinct, cogent, and complete.
But in the midst of that fierce declaration, the confession takes a detour. There's an abrupt tonal shift, the punch is pulled, and instead we get the rote neo-Cistercian self-flagellation of the Presbyterian People's Front.
Meaning, all of a sudden we've donned our best intersectional sackcloth, mourning our Complicity in such pressing contemporary crises as...checks notes..."manifest destiny." What follows, if one knows generic progressive discourse, is the usual performative litany of historical wrongs. We're colonialist, and racist, and sexist, ableist and queer-o-phobic, all of us damnable sinners, pie Crenshaw domine, dona eis requiem, whack.
I find this both baffling and frustrating, for a variety of reasons, three of which I'll pitch out here.
First, all of these lamentations seem to operate under the assumption that the PC(USA) is made up entirely of cisgender White men who can trace their lineage back to the Mayflower.
"We have," the Proposed New Confession intones, again and again, but that "We" is not a "We" that the church as a whole can confess together. Sure, our demographic skew is heavily towards being the Presbyterian Home of Honkeytown, but...and I don't know if you've noticed this...that's not who all of us are now.
Can a Korean American choir director or a Ghanaian elder claim to have reviled their immigrant neighbors? Can a historically Black church say that it has covered itself in racism's robes? Can the women who make up a supermajority of our membership lament their complicitness in their own self-denigration? Can the Queer folk who have fought for decades for inclusion declare themselves morally responsible for the harm inflicted upon them? None of them can, not meaningfully.
All of these Christians are (and here I'll turn on all caps) PART OF THE (PC)USA. They are not they. They are us. They are we. Yet those members of our shared fellowship are all positioned as the objects of the confession, not the ones proclaiming it. It's an exclusionary, neosegregationist liturgy, which is jarring given the confession's stated purpose.
Second, it just doesn't resemble the PC(USA) I've known for the entirety of my 57 years as a cradle Presbyterian. Every Presbyterian congregation I have worshiped in, been a member of, or pastored? None of them have lived out their lives together in a way that would justify these laments. In the more recent cases, be it the civil rights movement, the ordination of women, the inclusion of Queer folk, or the embrace of those who live with disability? In every one of those instances, we've fought our way through to an authentic witness, and at nontrivial cost in relationship and membership. Saying, for example, "You took a consistent stand for women's voices, but, you know you could have done more, and you're part of The Patriarchy, so you are automatically complicit?"
I don't buy it. I've looked at it, sat with it, thought about it, and...no. One cannot repent for a sin they have not committed. We have plenty of concrete and material sins to attend to, and repentance...understood from the whole witness of Scripture...just does not work that way. Here, I'm very much aware that I'm not compliant with the demands of our particular denominational Newspeak. I still view persons as the fundamental unit of moral analysis, for example. I'm guilty of so many doubleplus ecclesiastical thoughtcrimes. Mea culpa.
And finally, it feels, and here forgive me...Old. Not just Old, but Old Old, in a very particular gerontological way.
The laments themselves are cast in semi-chronological order, a retelling-in-negation of the history of the Presbyterian church in this country. They are decades out of date and centuries passed, sepia and crumbling. None of them, not one, meaningfully reflects the PC(USA) now, or the specific crisis we inhabit.
It's almost like we don't know where we are anymore, like we can't remember what we did yesterday, or the names of the people around us. But oh, do we remember the past, past struggles, past traumas, and past conflicts. We remember when we mattered, back when we once shaped the direction of a nation, when our voice made a difference. Remember at the General Assembly of 1818, when we let expediency and groupthink water down our witness, where we made a bold statement and then equivocated? Remember when we marched at Selma? No-one else remembers that, not anymore, but we're lost in the thrall of wouldacouldashoulda. It's a little solipsistic, a little maudlin, and more than a little morbid.
This section reads, to be blunt, like the deathbed confession of White Liberal Christianity.
"The Deathbed Confession?"
Do we want that to be what this is? An end of life groan of regret at mistakes made and things left undone, croaked from dry and dying White throats as the denomination falls into the Consuming Fire? Maybe we do. Maybe that is what we want. I know that's what some of y'all want.
The time for that church is over, some folks say. It should just cash out. Think of the things we could do with that money! Choose any charity! Give to the poor!
But again,"The Deathbed Confession" has kind of a ring to it, if we're talking brand identity.
As a foundation on which to build, though, and a naming of the spiritual battle facing the church, this section might not be the best step forward.
Because we're not dead yet.
To those who've labored long and hard over this work, in the unlikely event you find yourself reading these reflections: I recognize that some of these responses might feel uncomfortable. But, you know, just sit with them for a little while. And anyway, it's just one portion of one section, and y'all did ask for responses. I mean, you did.
There's so much more to the Confession than this, though, and I'll get to that in another post.
Thursday, April 23, 2026
A Scripture for the President
Tuesday, March 17, 2026
Enduring Fury
Friday, February 7, 2025
Hating the Samaritan
Samaritan's Purse, if you don't know it, is an evangelical relief organization, one that does tremendous work to bring lifegiving support to places of crisis in the world. They're competently run and remarkably bold in stepping into areas of crisis to provide food, medicine, and emergency support. I have friends who have witnessed first hand the good work they're doing, particularly in Sudan and Haiti.
Workers for relief agencies work side-by-side in desperate conditions, even as they may come from different national and ideological backgrounds. Those workers face violence, desperation, and privation, all to ensure the hungry are fed, the thirsty have water, and those wrenched from their homes by war or natural disaster are cared for.
It's heroic work, and every effort counts.
Which makes Graham's statement about USAID utterly incomprehensible. USAID was founded during the Cold War to use American soft power to push back against Soviet propaganda. Like the Marshall Plan, the goal was to win the hearts and minds of the world by showing that we as a nation were noble, honorable, and generous. It provides relief in precisely the areas where Samaritan's Purse operates. And yet Franklin Graham said the following about it yesterday:
"USAID, under the control of the Democratic left, has been pushing LGBTQ, transgender, and other godless agendas to the world in the name of the United States of America. We the taxpayers have been paying for this to the tune of billions of dollars. Thank you Elon Musk for exposing this—and now President Donald J. Trump is bringing it to an end. I encourage the State Department to continue providing life-saving aid like food and medicine."
Is this true?
The first sentence has some truth to it, as do most well spun falsehoods. A tiny fraction of the USAID budget has been used to support organizations that assert that Queer folks are human beings with rights. But the second sentence does not follow from the first, and what it implies is false. Yes, the USAID budget is in the billions, but those billions are spent on economic development, humanitarian assistance, and health initiatives.
Because faith-based initiatives are a major part of American identity, much of that money goes to support the efforts of Christian relief efforts. The largest single recipient of USAID funding, at over $4 billion dollars, is Catholic Relief Services. World Vision and Lutheran World Relief and the Presbyterian Church in East Africa have also been significant USAID partners, with total annual giving to Christian organizations in the billions of dollars. USAID also buys billions of dollars of food for emergency relief from American farmers.
Franklin Graham knows this. He knows this because his own organization received $90,000,000 from USAID over the last four years. Ninety million dollars. Samaritan's Purse alone receives ten times as much USAID funding as all of the grants supporting Queer folk combined. Watch this far right propaganda video listing every "offensive" grant they could find, and add up the amounts. It's not even close.
Again, this is not meant to in any way denigrate Samaritan's Purse, which does excellent work. They're worthy of support. But Franklin Graham should know better. I think, on some level, he does know better. But when you've bent the knee to Powers and Principalities, and made your witness subordinate to a decadent worldly authority, you must parrot the lies that they tell. And that dissonance makes you angrier and angrier, as you shout down the voice of grace in your own heart.
Perhaps the greatest irony in all of this is that Graham seems to have completely forgotten the point of an obscure story Jesus told. Maybe you've heard of it? The one about the Samaritan?
That parable was about how we approach those who we consider our enemies, yet through the fruits of their actions show themselves to be our neighbors. Samaritans were hated by Judeans, considered unfaithful and idolatrous and traitors to the faith. Yet it was the good work of a Samaritan that Jesus honored, as a way of telling us who we are to love as much as we love ourselves.
It's straight up, right there, front and center. But Lord have mercy, we mortals are so good at missing the point.
Tuesday, October 29, 2024
What's the Frequency, Kenneth?
"We have every right there is to tell the Devil: 'You take your hands off this nation!'" roared televangelist Kenneth Copeland, who put on a U.S. flag jacket and red MAGA hat when he took the stage.The scene could have come from any of the hard-right Christian road shows now barnstorming the country, with a focus on swing states in a razor-close election. Extremism analysts say the tours serve as both a get-out-the-vote juggernaut and power flex for a Christian supremacist movement that aims to transform the church the same way MAGA did the GOP: by forcing out moderates.Ministers like Copeland preach that Christianity is the bedrock of American identity and should influence all aspects of society, ideas central to Christian nationalism."
Monday, July 29, 2024
A Vote to Save Trump's Soul
Monday, July 15, 2024
Praying for Donald Trump
How to pray for Donald J. Trump following the attempt on his life? As a Christian, I'm duty-bound to pray for my enemies as deeply as I pray for my friends, which is enough of a challenge. But the specifics of the prayer were a unique conundrum.
I mean, had he been seriously or critically hurt, and hospitalized, that would have been straightforward. I'd have prayed for his recovery, and for his doctors, and for healing for the nation. That was the simple prayer offered back when he was afflicted with COVID, and things looked touch and go for a while. Had he died, that would also have been straightforward, prayers for the disposition of his soul and again, for the healing of the nation.
But Donald J. Trump is fine.
He could have died, yes, but he did not.
He was aggressive before, he was more aggressive after. His injury, such as it was, was the sort of thing one might get in a moderate fall. It was of less import than a sprained ankle, and far less of an impediment to his life. Nor did his response indicate any meaningful psychological trauma, or any reaction other than unshakable defiance and an even deeper conviction of his own special place in history.
I shared this observation during a conversation with a Trump supporter yesterday after church, and they agreed. "He's fine," they said.
In point of fact, he is stronger after the attempt than he was before the attempt, and he knows it.
He is just as physically healthy, albeit with a surface wound to his ear. He is far socially stronger, as the "iconic" images of his deeply ingrained fight response have cemented the messianic convictions of his most fervent supporters. Their collective victim-narrative is now sealed in his own blood, so to speak.
He will step into the Republican convention this next week as a bloodied and unbowed hero, fist raised in defiance, and be received with roars of adulation.
He isn't in mourning, or in shock. He's fine, and feeling fine. He is reveling in this moment, the purest gift to a consummate showman.
That's not a partisan assessment, but the simple reality.
So my prayers were simpler. For healing for his ear, such as it is. For the disposition of his soul, as always. And, particularly, for the future of this country, and a turning away from the bitter spirit of violence that so blights us all.
Monday, November 13, 2023
SNAP, Pantries, and Christian Nations
They arrive in a van, laden with seven to eight hundred of pounds of food, which their temple has purchased to help support the efforts of our bustling Little Free Pantry. Volunteers from the church join together with the nuns, hefting forty pound bags of carrots and onions. Crates of potatoes and apples, pallets of canned soups and sauces.
All of it will flow through the Pantry over the course of a week, as folks in the community who need food support pull into our gravel parking lot. It will join the generous donations given by members of the church, and by the good decent folks out in our little town.
When church folk started our Little Free Pantry...think a Little Free Library, only for nonperishable food...we'd not known what to expect. We'd anticipated it to be a modest supplement to the nonprofit Food Bank that already exists in our community, just across the street, hosted by our Methodist neighbors. It was simply something to handle the off-hours when those food bank shelves weren't available.
For a while, that was precisely what it was.
But debt-addicted America printed trillions of new dollars into the economy during the pandemic, which had the surprising effect of triggering inflation. Golly, who coulda seen that coming? And then, with costs rising ahead of wages, we cut back on the SNAP benefits that had been a lifeline for families during the pandemic. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program feeds tens of millions in our country, and after it was expanded during COVID, that retraction had a notable impact here in the trenches of food provision.
Sure, the pandemic was over, but inflation had changed the entire economic dynamic, and millions suddenly found that affording little luxuries like housing, transportation, and food had become unmanageable.
Nearly thirty thousand pounds.
Across the way at the local food bank, demand is up fifty percent.
This is the reality. This is what's happening on the ground. Up in the cold airless aether of ideological
blather, the conversations in the House of Representatives have turned to cutting SNAP further. It's "bloated and broken," or so say those who claim to want to offer a "hand up, not a hand out."
Now, I don't have a problem with making programs more efficient. I don't doubt there are layers of bureaucracy that could be trimmed away. It's a food program, not a jobs program. So do that, sure. But anything that results in less food for the hungry, or that creates more bureaucratic processes, procedures, and protocols for people in need to negotiate? That's not the kind of country a free and decent folk would want to live in.
And I don't have any issue with empowering people to be self-supporting. But the people who need food are working people. They need those calories so they can work to support themselves. Having food is a hand up. Offering people platitudes instead of plates of food only makes sense if you're the sort of fool who thinks you can live by eating ideology. It's indecent.
On a fundamental level, that's also not Christian, bruh. It ain't Buddhist, neither, but being that I'm a pastor and Jesus is my Lord and Savior, I can only speak with authority about the former.
Seriously. There's a deep irony that the same folks who wrap themselves in flag and cross and declare that America must be a Christian nation? They're the folks who want America to do exactly the opposite thing that Christians are commanded to do.
We feed people. Because Jesus. Told. Us. To. This isn't complicated. He ain't your Lord and Savior if you don't do what he tells you to do.
Lord have mercy, have these folk even read their Bibles?
Tuesday, October 24, 2023
Trump Antichrist
Monday, May 8, 2023
Widows and Orphans
Thursday, December 3, 2020
When Alternate Realities Collide
Arguably. But I'm going with it.
It is and will continue to be my assumption that God's creation is more than our spacetime. Instead, I view God's creative work as an infinite panoply of all potential reality, in which everything that can possibly exist does exist. It's very much a minority position, and the sort of thing that would have meant all sorts of serious unpleasantness for me if I'd lived in an era where heresy wasn't the norm. Yay separation of church and state!
That perspective has been strangely tested of late, as America is increasingly rent apart by competing narratives about what is real and what is good. There are two diametrically opposed visions of reality at play, each of which stands in radical opposition to the other.
On the one hand, there is the narrative of a President who is a charismatic, straight-talking, no-nonsense businessman. He tells it like it is, seeks to restore a nation to true faith and its rightful greatness, and "has a heart" for the common man. He stands against a corrupt, sinister, and decadent cabal of secretive elites, who are doing everything they can to strip him of his rightful leadership.
On the other hand, there is the narrative of a President who is a charismatic huckster and charlatan. He lies as easily as he breathes, and has dog whistled, worm-tongued, or bought his way into the confidence of millions. Seeking attention, power and his own enrichment, he is now attempting to overthrow the results of an election, while those who are not bamboozled resist his despotic designs.
Both of these narratives cannot describe a single person, or a single reality. They can be independently true, in separate universes. If a theistic multiverse is your cosmology, as it is mine, they do. In the infinite glory of God's manifold providence, a being named "Donald J. Trump" is both of those things. Many other things too, like an animated meat toaster and a seven winged seraph, but let's stick with those two realities for now. They are both "real," in that they may well exist in their respective corners of the multiverse.
But those realities cannot coexist in one time and space as descriptors of a particular entity. Truth and reality are complicated, sure, and we human beings are none of us perfect. But there is a difference between personal complexity and antithesis, between accurate description and fundamental error.
If I step outside and say "It is raining right now," I am making a specific statement about reality. It is either true or it is not.
Now, one might try to obfuscate or qualify that statement. "Well, what if it's drizzling?" "What do you mean by 'right now'" "Does a sun shower count?" "Did you know that the Xuatatla people have forty seven words for rain?" But then you are being willfully stupid, the sort of stupid that comes when we use reason to overthrow common sense.
Either there is a massive conspiracy to commit fraud, or a pathological narcissist and those in his thrall are lying. It is either part of our reality or not. There is no Hegelian synthesis between the two. And unlike statements about higher order realities like Love, Purpose, and God, a statement about material reality is provable. There must be evidence that affirms or denies the truth we claim.
Were I to contact you via email and let you know that I currently have 125,327 Bitcoin in my accidentally frozen Coinbase account, and ask to use that as collateral for a personal loan from you, you'd need some evidence of that assertion. If I couldn't give you that affirmation, you could still take me at my word. But that'd be foolish.
The assertions of election fraud are precisely the same thing. There is no evidence to verify them. They simply did not happen. They are not part of our reality. Nor are the assertions that the vaccine is a tool of a demonic elite cabal. Nor are any of the fevered fabulisms of QAnon. None of these things are real. Not one has a place in our corner of creation. They have no foundation at all.
When we make statements about our reality that have no basis in that reality, then we are mistaken, delusional, or lying. Mistakes? We all make them. They can be corrected. It's part of growing and learning.
Delusions and lies are more dangerous than mistakes, because they are fiercely resilient. They do not yield to correction. Nor do they yield to evidence, because they never relied on evidence in the first place. They represent the semiotic incursion into our reality of something fundamentally alien to it, as if another realm of being was trying to press into our own to define it.
For the soul in thrall of a delusion, their delusion must be defended at all costs. There is no evidence because that evidence IS BEING HIDDEN. IT GOES DEEPER THAN WE EVER THOUGHT!
Or, if you know you're lying, this is where one lie leads to another deeper lie, which will lead to another and another.
That's what has made the "reality" pitched out by conspiracy theorists, radical ideologues, and propagandists so damaging to the arc of our history. Those false narratives, those "alternative facts?" They make a truth claim that isn't simply unfalsifiable, but is actually the antithesis of the sliver of creation that we inhabit. It does not belong here.
There's an archaic word, one used by more primal peoples. It describes what happens when something alien to our reality tries to take control of it...and of us. It's a word that's a bit awkward on the tongues of the overeducated, and has what could at best be considered a checkered history.
That word is "demonic."
Thursday, October 29, 2020
Why I voted FOR Biden.
I recognize that this election season is all about opposing your opponent. It's about coalescing around hatred for ones enemy, about tapping into that group energy that comes from having a person you can focus your anger on.
It's classical Alinskian politics, after all. Nothing motivates human beings more than having a villain to fight, a face to put on your hate, a heel to boo and hiss and attack. And Lord have mercy, do we have that energy going on right now.
But though I feel that spirit out there mightily, and it rises up on the wings of my anger about clear threats to the integrity of the republic, I also don't really trust that energy. It's evil, after all. And my Teacher doesn't fight evil with evil, no matter what Palpatine might be hissing at me on Twitter.
I take a deep breath, center away from that form of power, and try to think positively. Where is the good in my choosing? How does seeking the good...not just my own, but of the republic I love...drive how I will act as a citizen? I have already voted, going early because, well...it seems necessary this year.
So let me say this: I voted for Joe Biden because he's a decent person who will be a decent, competent president. When I voted, I did not do so grudgingly, or with reservations. I am not simply voting *against* someone. I want Joe Biden to be president. Frankly, I wanted him to run in 2016, and was disappointed when he made the choice to step aside. My decision to cast my vote for Biden is affirmative, not a "best of two bad choices" or a poke in the eye to those who see the world so very differently than I. There are reasons for this. Let me lay 'em out for ya.
1) Biden is a moderate. I am also a moderate. Well, moderate in some things. I am moderate in my moderation. But generally, I don't believe in abrupt change, or in moving suddenly unless there's a truck coming at you. Evolution is life's path through the order of creation, and it is also the best way to accomplish necessary adaptation. Abrupt changes to living systems are likely to fail. Moderates consider the possible good on either side of a contentious issue, and find the path that makes the most sense given the reality we inhabit. Not the pipe dream of a perfect future, or the lie of a perfect past, but the reality of where we are, who we are right now, and how we might take that step to become better.
I see that logic in most of what Biden does. Take, for instance, Biden's stance on busing, for which he was attacked during the primary season. Busing was, quite frankly, a shortsighted solution to a real problem. Decoupling students and parents from local schools is an ideologues idea of an answer to systemic failures in our school systems. I would vote against any candidate who proposed it, because there's value in community, and in not having to drive halfway across the damn county to bring my kid something they forgot, or to pick 'em up when the nurse calls. It's not racist to oppose it, because race isn't the only thing at play when it comes to busing.
Moderates think about such things, and I am voting for Biden because he is a moderate.
2) Biden knows how to work with others. Again, this is because Biden isn't a radical or an egotist. He doesn't see politics as a zero sum game, but understands that you're better off at least trying to connect with those who aren't your base. He's representative of a better time in American politics, when folks were willing to reach across party lines to get things done. A better time, frankly, than the one we inhabit. He's got a track record of this, a lifetime of evidence that he is willing to find common ground and treat those who disagree with him honorably.
He is a liberal, in the classical sense of the term. Liberality is the enemy of radicalism, and has always been. It is neither leftist nor right-wing. In the Soviet Union, it was the liberals who were harassed and imprisoned. In Nazi Germany, liberality was equally attacked. Why? Because liberals are a threat to every form of authoritarianism. They insist on listening to and considering the potential merits of other positions. Liberality also assumes that the person you are talking to is not a caricature, but an actual human being. Kindness, grace, mercy, and understanding are liberal virtues. Biden is a liberal in the most traditional sense of the word.
In part, that comes from his persona. Let's talk about that.
3) Biden is a centering presence. Tone matters in leadership, as it does in all relationships. Try saying something to your wife in a gentle tone. Now say it in a snarky, bullying tone. Which one is more likely to have you sleeping on the sofa?
Biden listens. He is genuinely the kind of person who cares. It's why he's been around as long as he has, because it's not just a facade or a schtick. It's his identity.
If you want to unify a nation, there are different approaches to doing that. The best approach is to appeal to the center, to reach out to the best shared spirit of a people. That calls a nation together. It unites from common purpose, and from a position of shared hope and determination. It is the path of nations that are growing and moving forward.
You can also use darker energies to force unity. Fear and hatred are excellent tools for pulling a people...or a subset of people...towards a given end. They can be powerful. These work well when coupled with brute force. If a people aren't united by common purpose, you can motivate a subset of them with fear of an enemy, then use the coercive power of a police state to subdue and subjugate the rest of them.
A leader must express that, particularly if they want to lead more than a subset of partisans. If you want a nation to cohere, and if you dislike divisiveness, you need to choose leaders who refuse to use the energy of division and disruption. Seek the measured, the thoughtful, and the leader who will acknowledge and respect a worthy perspective, even if it is offered by a political adversary.
That said, there's always the concern that a moderate leader won't be able to push back when pressed, that they'll not have the necessary spine to resist when the integrity of the nation is attacked or pressed by a hostile aggressor.
After the first debate, we know what he looks like responding to blind aggression now, so, yeah. That one's fine.
4) Biden is old.
He is not young. For many folks, this is spun as a negative. Joe Biden is 77. He isn't hip and edgy and now. Farthest thing from it. But with age can come wisdom. A lifetime of experience is not irrelevant, nor is it irrelevant that he understands the ebb and flow of political fads. I don't buy into the idea that age is only a negative. Jesus Mary and Joseph, it's not like we're living in the world of Logan's Run. Well, not quite yet, anyway.
I value the vision and depth of those who have lived more years than I, seen more things than I, and know more than I. I understand things in middle age that I did not in my youth. Every year, my well of experience deepens.
There are two concerns, of course. First, that age can come with significant diminishment of cognitive function. Which is why I've made a point of listening to Biden speak off the cuff, and listening to him answering questions. Not for just a soundbite, but for a whole hour of speaking, unfiltered by any spin. He's not the best at it, not as good as Obama or even as Reagan. But neither is he incompetent.
Second, that age can calcify a person's perspective, and make them less likely to respond effectively to a new and unanticipated challenge. Old dogs often go back to the same bag of tricks, over and over and over again. It's a human tendency, and one I feel in myself as I get more curmudgeonly with age. To counterbalance this, you need liberality, a willingness to see the good in the new, and one other thing. You also have to have people who you respect to teach you things you don't already know. Which gets me to the next point.
5) Biden is more than Biden.
He isn't perfect, and he doesn't pretend to be. But Biden is the sort of leader who knows to listen to wise counsel. He does not assume he knows everything, or that his opinions are the only ones that matter. A Biden presidency would engage the minds of other human beings, tapping into deeper expertise and acknowledging that one single person cannot know all things.
If your understanding of leadership is that good leaders are strong and in complete control of everything, that might not work for you. Some folks assume that a leader who doesn't just give orders and demand loyalty is somehow "inauthentic." As a pastor who cares for my community and from my doctoral work in leadership dynamics, I know that churches...and by extension, any human group...that are run by one person with ultimate power? They fail.
The strong church...or organization, or nation...is the one where the gifts and wisdom of the whole group are utilized. Expertise is not smothered by ideology or ego. The power of the team, and the strengths we all bring? They all need to be brought forward. In a time when we are tested by a hornet's nest of crises, we need that kind of leadership.
6) Biden personally manifests the Christian virtues.
This isn't going to work for everyone, as not everyone is Christian. But I am. The teachings of Jesus define my path, and while I'm the farthest thing from perfect, I measure my success as a soul by how I do what Jesus asks me to do. What that looks like as we live day to day is defined well by the classical Christian virtues. There are many different ways to present that set of morals, but one of the clearest is found in ancient Christian teachings about vice, sin, and the virtues that counterbalance them.
The Seven Deadly sins, we know. Lust. Gluttony. Greed. Sloth. Wrath. Envy. Pride. Give power to a person ruled by those sins, and they will cause harm. Against them...not in parallel but on their own terms... we find arrayed the angels of the Seven Virtues. Chastity. Temperance. Charity. Diligence. Patience. Kindness. Humility. Give authority to a soul that has tapped into the power of these graces, and they will be a blessing.
Let's break those virtues down. Chastity means containing carnal desire through fidelity in relationships. Temperance expresses itself through moderation of impulses, by refusing to allow the momentary impulse to drive your choosing. Charity means benevolence, a willingness to sacrifice self for the greater good, and a turning away from the hunger to maximize personal benefit at the expense of other. Diligence means putting in the hard work necessary to do a thing. Good things take time, dedication, and focus. Patience means playing the long game, ignoring the provocation of the moment and keeping your heart turned towards your purpose always. Kindness requires a concern for others and their wellbeing, and for that concern to govern your behavior towards all. Kindness rejoices in and magnifies the successes of others. Humility creates in us a willingness to learn, an openness to be changed when we are wrong, and a servants heart.
I see all of these spirits working in Joe Biden, and not just now, but over the many years we've been able to watch him in public service. Is he perfect? No. None of us are. But you can tell from his life where his priorities lie, and how his deeply held lifelong faith forms and shapes who he is. You shall know them by their fruits, as my Teacher said.
7) Joe Biden Loves to Drive.
This isn't going to work for everyone, because not everyone loves cars the way that I have since I was a little boy. But Joe Biden's a car guy. I love cars. Sweet baby Jesus, do I love cars. Biden still owns the same Corvette he bought back when he was a young man, and clearly takes pleasure in it. The thing he hated most about being VP was not being able to get out and drive. He likes the feel of a fast car, the elemental pleasure of being behind the wheel.
As it so happens, the first truly fast car I ever drove was my uncle's '65 Stingray. Fuel injected 327, sky blue, gorgeous. Dang, was that fun.
This is, I'll admit, a silly thing, but I know that were I to ever meet Biden, I'd have trouble ending the conversation. Because God help me, I can blabber on about cars all day long. Just ask my congregants. So while I feel some lament about depriving Joe of that for the next four years, well...I can appreciate him.









