Showing posts with label dow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dow. Show all posts

Thursday, June 25, 2026

Strange Division


It’s been a while since I struggled to understand division. It was third grade, if I’m recalling correctly, when I’d come trudging home from Timberlane Elementary School with a backpack full of math worksheets requiring me to do exciting things like divide 567 by 32, rounding up to the tens place.

Once you knew your times tables, it wasn’t so hard, but it took a while to get there, bludgeoning my way through exercise after exercise until I finally got it.

I had a peculiarly similar experience a few months ago, as in my fifty-seventh year of life I finally realized I had no idea how the Dow Jones Industrial Average actually worked. I peruse the business news daily, and for years thought I had the basic principle down. The Dow, which is used to measure the economic health of a nation, is a number you get to by adding together the dollar value of common stock in thirty selected blue chip companies. That gives you the dividend/numerator. This, you divide by a divisor/denominator….in this case, 30…to get an average. Because, you know, that’s how averages work, or so I remember from later in elementary school. That measure of economic health has risen meteorically in my lifetime, going from 800 in 1969 to over 50,000 now. For a long time, I assumed the soaring DOW had to do with two factors: 1) that stocks were gaining value and 2) that the dollar was losing value through inflation.

But I was wrong.

That’s not how it works. Not at all. I was right about the dividend, but clueless about the divisor. When the DOW began, the divisor was the number of stocks in the average. But the folks who run the Dow have gradually adjusted that divisor downwards over the last 75 years, to create a narrative of “continuity.” So instead of dividing by thirty, which would give you an actual average, or by 1, as was the case in 1987, the year I graduated from high school, you now divide by point one six. 

Point one six.

And when you divide by a number that’s less than one, what happens? All of a sudden, you’re multiplying!

This, conveniently enough, gives us the story of endless growth. 

Growth, as any parent or gardener can tell you, is a fundamental part of life. That’s the core narrative of our economic culture, that things must always be more and be better and bigger and more powerful. It’s what we’re taught to revere, taught to value, and it’s the story that defines whether our lives have worth or our lives do not. It is the defining moral purpose of the culture that birthed us, and in which our identities are formed and shaped.

It’s fiercely seductive, and I’m not immune to the siren song of bright and shiny things.

But that story of ever rising power and wealth isn’t entirely true. What is the DJIA but Standard and Poors telling the tale of a government that prints more and more money, and businesses that print more and more stocks to absorb that new money into the portfolios of the privileged?

More notably, for those of us who follow Jesus, how much does Mammon's peculiarly self-serving mathematics shape how we live out our lives as disciples?

Thursday, March 7, 2013

The Cake is a Lie

The markets are soaring lately, riding high after high and crest after crest.

In point of fact, the Dow Jones Industrial Average now stands at record levels.  It's a bumper crop!  A jackpot!   A total economic turnaround from those disastrous days after the 2008 crash!  Look!  Stock values have more than doubled, with the Dow going from sixty-eight hundred and change to over fourteen thousand.

Things are awesome!

Only, they aren't.   The Dow, as even a math-challenged minister such as myself can easily observe, does not empirically measure the health of an economy.  It measures one thing: A price-weighted index of 30 stocks in United States dollars.  

What we know is that these stocks now cost nearly twice...in United States dollars...what they did in 2008.  Are there significantly more jobs?  No, not particularly.  Is there a revolutionary new force driving real economic growth?  No, there's not.  Job growth has been meh.  Incomes for all but the very top are flat, and the average household income has been falling.

What there has been a great deal more of over the last five years is money.  For five years, we've been printing money...in the form of the Fed buying bonds.   We've been doing that to the tune of $85 billion dollars every single month.

And so the exuberance on the part of Wall Street traders at the continuing surge of stock prices seems peculiar to me.  Would we be celebrating if the price of milk had doubled?  Or the price of gas?  Why should we similarly celebrate if the price of entry into the Capitalist Cornucopia has doubled?

In the absence of any significant increase in production or improvement in the real economy, what appears to have happened is a simple absorption.  We've printed money, and that money has gone directly into capital markets.  Given the absence of material growth, dollars are worth less, which means the number of dollars required to purchase stock is higher.

I cannot see any other logical way to interpret what I'm seeing.

Meaning that taste in your mouth is not cake.