Immediately following the assassination attempt in Pennsylvania, the religious chatter about Trump got waaaaay more intense.
Tuesday, July 23, 2024
Speculation and Morality
Immediately following the assassination attempt in Pennsylvania, the religious chatter about Trump got waaaaay more intense.
Thursday, June 13, 2024
Of Trump and Jesus
Both were prosecuted and convicted of crimes by the state.
Therefore, they are the same."
This seems to be the logic permeating a substantial portion of American Christianity of late, the portion that sees Jesus and Donald Trump as essentially equivalent persons. Trump is, by this way of thinking, a martyr, whose struggle is our struggle. The only reason he is being pursued is that he is the only one who can speak up for the little guy, the only one who knows and speaks the truth. And like Jesus, he is willing to pay the price for his truth-telling.
This is, of course, utterly insane.
One could just as easily place Adolph Hitler into that Venn Diagram, only Hitler actually went to prison for the beer-fueled uprising he instigated in Munich. Like Hitler, the trial and conviction of Adolph Hitler only cemented his popularity among his followers, for precisely the same reason that Trumpists take Trump's convictions as a marker of his legitimacy. Only a true patriot would be willing to suffer for us! Just like Jesus! And Hitler! Yay TrumpJesusHitler!
But just as Jesus and Adolph were nothing alike, so too Donald and Jesus are nothing alike.
The two bear no resemblance to one another whatsoever morally or personally. They are, in point of fact, the opposite sort of person entirely. Making the argument that they are the same is a marker of a disordered mind.
"Are you saying my mind is disordered?" might come the snarled aggression response from the avowed Trumpist, who has learned that threats and bullying are their most effective tools in silencing opponents.
Yes. Yes I am. Insofar as you are in thrall, yes.
But I will admit that there's something inaccurate about my statement.
That way of putting it assumes that Trumpism is a physical pathology, a peculiar and pernicious neurodivergence or imbalance in brain chemistry.
It is not.
Trumpism is first and foremost a moral disease, the same moral disease that has afflicted humankind since we were first driven from Eden. It is the willingness to blame others for our own mistakes. It is the desire to resent, to attack, and to manipulate truth to our own ends. It is the hate of one's enemies, and the love of mammon, and the delight in violence and violent thoughts.
It is a disorder of the soul, a spiritual illness.
To use some pointlessly overcomplicated words, Trumpism is a sociopolitical manifestation of Augustinian concupiscence. It tastes of the fruit of the knowledge of evil, its' sickly sticky siren song sweet as Turkish Delight straight from the cold hand of Jadis.
There, I suppose, you do have your theological connection, because the reason we human beings need Jesus so utterly is our hunger to be ruled by men like Donald.
Friday, October 23, 2009
Bad Data
This weekend, two new movies will arrive in our nation's Cine-MegaPlexes. One is part of a familiar franchise, one that's moved countless buckets of popcorn and cheez-drowned Nachitos over the past decade. The other is one-a dem furrin' films. You know. Moody. Existential. Independent, with a director who views it as deeply conceptual and who has a particular vision as an auteur.The cinematic extravaganzas in question are Saw VI and Antichrist, and while they may seem to appeal to different audiences, they are cut from the same cloth and of the same genre. In an excellent essay in the WaPo yesterday, movie critic Anne Hornaday pegged the connection. Both are what cinephiles have come to describe as "torture porn," films that focus on the relentless and graphic depiction of the bloody torment of other human beings.
Both movies attempt to make the case that they are, in fact, furthering human understanding. The underlying premise behind the Saw franchise is, apparently, that the threat of a slow and horrible death inflicted on our helpless body by a sadistic psychopath enables us to better appreciate life. A few years back, I remember one of our Sunday School teachers suggested integrating that into our third grade curriculum. It didn't go over well.
Antichrist is a bit less like something written by Dr. Phil's sociopathic younger brother. It's more intentionally obscure, more aware that it is not a movie. It is not meant to entertain. It is Film! It is Art! It's array of misogynistic and increasingly harrowing images have something to do with the power dialectic between reason and emotion, male and female, sexuality, self-affirmation and self-mutilation. Though it's made by a Dane, he's evidently one of those Danes who hasn't discovered the pleasures of a good beer. It feels more High German, with a vision probably expressed best with some long technical made up word, like, say, dafoeingeweideblutforterungschafft.
Sigh. We Americans are just so..provincial.
Here, I feel a strange desire to go all Father Ted standing self-righteous with a sign outside of the theater. It's painfilth! It's degrading hurtsmut! Stay away! Down with that sort of thing!
I won't do that, tempting though it may be. But prog though I am, I can honestly see no reason to watch films that serve up meticulously presented brutality for our prurient delectation and amusement. I mean, jeez. I had to watch the Passion of the Christ once for church, and I never ever want to go through that again. Torture porn is a spiritually blighted genre, one into which Jesus-folk should wander only with deep caution. Better yet, stay away.
Some of my fellow progs might disagree. I am being judgmental. Prejudiced, even, given that I won't go see those films. Art that expresses human suffering is still art, they might say. Speech that revels in and celebrates inflicting mortal pain is still speech, they would suggest. What right do I have to make value judgments about things that other people enjoy or find expresses the human condition?
Discernment is just so...unpomo.
I am convinced, though, that storytelling and the images and ideas we take in transform us as persons. They are not passive expressions of what is, but help form us and shape us. It's part of the reason Jesus told stories to get his point across, eh? When we take in images of brutality and cruelty as a form of entertainment, it coarsens us. Stunts us.
It is, in programming terms, bad code.


