Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Moses and the Journey to Leadership

The second in the sequence of books for my D.Min. program is Moses and the Journey to Leadership:  Timeless Lessons of Effective Management from the Bible and Today's Leaders, by Dr. Norman J. Cohen.  Dr. Cohen is a Professor of Midrash at Hebrew Union College, and it shows.

The book is layered through with tellings and retellings of Torah, both from the primary narrative and from the secondary/legendary traditions of Midrash.  Dr. Cohen continually drops into a patois of blended Hebrew and English, peppering transliterated words into the flow of the narrative both for flavor and to engage in impromptu word-study.  It's a pretty standard rabbinic schtick, one that made reading through the book reminiscent of listening to the rabbi expound on Torah at my family's synagogue during the High Holy Days.

In reacting to the text, I had several challenges as I schlepped my way through the reading.

The first was that it seemed somewhat removed from the actual practice of leadership.  Given the scholarly/rabbinic character of the work, this is perhaps not surprising.  In an effort to relate the leadership of Moses to leadership dynamics in government and business, the text is smattered with pull-out boxes that describe semi-related leadership approaches in both government and business.  This was intended to give context, but after about the tenth pullout telling us, again, that Ernest Shackleton was a collaborative and positive leader, we get it already.   The general points were fine...be an inclusive leader, be sure of yourself, don't overfunction, involve and empower others...but they felt generic, underdeveloped, and cribbed from another primary source.

The style and dynamics of rabbinic explication also ended up feeling like a distraction.  The extensive and repeated explorations of the root meanings of words were fine in and of themselves, but felt a bit aimless in that meandering academic way.  In explaining the significance of the word rephidim, for instance, we are on page 79 told that it derives from the Hebrew term rafeh yadayim, meaning "weak hands."  Because the people squabble with God, their hands are weak.  But five pages later, we're told that rephidim derives from raphad, meaning "chair" or "support," because Moses needed the support of Aaron and Hur.  Recognizing that the rabbinic tradition is filled with such etymological exploration, and that the Hebrew language lends itself to polyvalent word-root speculation, it feels distractingly inconsistent.  Or perhaps just like an entertaining late night bull session at yeshiva.

I also stumbled over some of the interpretive work, particularly the efforts to reclaim and validate the Biblical injunction against being an Amalekite.  Or a breathing one, at least.  Where Cohen suggests that we should just understand Amalekites as symbolic representations of all that is evil in the world (p. 87), I just can't get there.  It's just an ugly bit of unpleasantness, if we're honest about it.   Not being a literalist, I see no need to read those passages as anything other than an unpleasant historical echo of ethnic tension that has been theologically spun.

Certain sections were more resonant, like the chapter exploring the need to empower individuals who support the vision laid out by the leader (ch. 9) and the last chapter, which dealt with the need for leaders to manage the inevitable transition to another leader.

The call and leadership struggles of Moses are a particularly powerful and resonant narrative for those who've been called to lead the church, and Cohen's exploration of that dynamic did have potential.  Ultimately, though, it felt disconnected from both a foundation in organizational praxis and in tenuous relationship with secular research on leadership effectiveness.

1 comment:

  1. Mái tóc đẹp luôn là niềm ao ước của nhiều chị em. luôn tìm cách để cho mình có được mái tóc đẹp như ý. Chính vì thế cho nên việc làm và tìm các kiểu tóc đẹp dễ làm trong mỗi thời gian luôn được các chị em quan tâm đến. Việc làm và dưỡng tóc hiện nay nhiều phương pháp khác nhau như thẩm my, dầu gội, sử dụng tinh dầu thiên nhiên. Chính vì thế các dịch vụ spa, dưỡng tóc hình thành nhằm đáp ứng nhu cầu ấy và tốt hơn hẳng ngày nay việc sử dụng tinh dầu thiên nhiên làm đẹp và dưỡng tóc ngày càng phổ biến cụ thể là ủ tóc bằng dầu dừa qua đêm sẽ cho bạn mái tóc khỏe mạnh nhanh chóng trong 1 tuần sử dụng. Không quá khó khăn cũng như công đoạn và cách thực hiện nhanh chóng có thể giúp bạn có mái tóc như ý. Và dầu dừa cũng là một trong nguyên liệu được áp dụng rộng rãi trong việc sử dụng cách làm cho tóc nhanh dài hiệu quả an toàn cho các chị em. Và sau khi bạn sở hữu được mái tóc dài chắc khỏe đen bóng thì việc còn lại bạn nên chọn lựa cho mình những kiểu tóc đẹp phù hợp với khuôn mặt và vóc dáng của mình và một trong những kiểu tóc luôn được các chị em phụ nữ chọn lựa cho mái tóc xoăn. Vậy các làm mái tóc xoăn như thế nào cúng chúng tôi tìm hiểu cách làm tóc xoăn đơn giản. Hy vọng vói thông tin chia sẻ trên bạn có thể chọn lựa cho mình cách dưỡng và làm đẹp tóc hiệu quả ngay tại nhà của mình nhé!

    ReplyDelete