Carol said over at tribalchurch, why diversity?
I mean, yeah, leftys and lib'rals tend to go on about how important it is to be inclusive. We could klatch endlessly about the liberation of transgendered Guatemalans living with dwarfism. Sorry, "little people." Or, oops, that's gente pequeña. Or transexuales poco de Guatemala. So hard to keep track of the lingo sometimes.
The reasons to care about difference, though, need to go well beyond simply wanting to include everyone because it's inclusive, even though that word makes us feel as warm and tingly as a hot brimming cup of fair trade Ethiopian Yergacheffe.
Here, I think Christian progressives tend to fall back on the language of secular liberal academe, and we do so to our failing. To my eyes, the deepest justification for diversity comes from within Scripture. The great narrative arc of the Tanakh, the Gospels, and the Epistles rings out with stories of how vitally important it is that we be open to the other.
Yeah, I know, you can spin it the other way. You can get all Ezra and kick out all them apostate furrin' wimmen and their mudblood children. If you're a social conservative in a strict constructionist sense, there are plenty of opportunities within the tradition to stand firm against the creep of "syncretism" and/or those voices that seem to chip away at the authority you know is your birthright. You can use the Bible to keep those loud whiny women in their place. You can scripturally shout down those uppity colored folk. But just 'cause it's the truth that affirms you in all you've been taught doesn't mean it won't wither to writhing embers in the hellfire of God's inexorable love.
From within the core metrics of our faith, there are some key operating assumptions about hearing the voices of folks different than us.
First, there's the Exodus presumption in favor of the stranger. At a bare minimum, those who are different and those who are outside of the boundaries of our culture and our should be met with welcome, grace, and kindness. Why? Because our mythopoetic memory is of having been strangers and slaves in the land of Egypt. When we cried out for deliverance, it was the cry of the oppressed other that was heard by the Lord. This is our story. If we approach the other...any other...without a heart of compassion, then we have failed to understand the essence of the Biblical narrative and our place within it.
Second, there's God's tendency to consistently use those who ain't part of "us" to school us, save us, or whup our behinds when they needs a whuppin'. The prophets through whom God spoke stood outside of the structures of human culture and power. They lived in the wilderness because those in power tended to drive them there, preferring instead the saccharine comforts of those who told them what they wanted to hear. God goes so far as to use even those who aren't part of the faith at all. When Israel forgot about covenant and justice and mercy, and got to be all about power and privilege, Babylon was an instrument in God's hands. When Israel wept, helpless and lost and broken by the rivers in Babylon, Cyrus of Persia was an instrument in God's hands to save them. God is not part of our culture. God is not part of any society. God is not "us." With us, yes. Working in us and through us, maybe. But if the Biblical narrative is to be ours, then we must live into the truth that God is present and active even in those who are radically other. If we want to hear our Creator, then we have to listen and be present with the other.
Finally, there's Christ's redemptive work. Yeah, that. Jesus reaffirms and radicalizes the Exodus favoring of the stranger. The teachings of Jesus of Nazareth are oriented towards deep and God-centered engagement with the other, and in particular the other who is ostracized, hated, or powerless. It is that baffling love for not just friends, not just family, but for the stranger and the enemy that makes Christianity a tradition that is 1) ever and always fundamentally countercultural and 2) worth following.
That isn't to say that Wuvvy Sparkleberry Jesus sprinkles lollipops and daisies on everyone. Those who have worldly power, be it coercive or economic, well...Jesus has words for them. Those words aren't easy ones. Why? Because defining ourselves in terms of society or the gun or the dollar turns us into adversaries of one another and of God. Those forms of power make us approach others not in love, but with the intent of alienating them, or subjugating them, or profiting from them.
The more deeply we engage with those that worldly power declares other, the tax-collectors and the centurions and the lepers and the unclean, the more we manifest the Kingdom.
That, it would seem, is reason enough to make diversity a priority for Christians.